Talk:The Cooper Extraction/@comment-251103-20131213092841/@comment-101.210.115.140-20131213140740

Good point. I think there is an ambiguity. Initially it seems they mean if Sheldon never existed or none of them ever met him. Later it becomes clear that without Sheldon and the guys meeting. That is Sheldon stays in his apartment and in due course of time Penny becomes his neighbour.